Sunday, May 08, 2011

The "New" Daily Racing Form

No list of the day's races and entries for many tracks (including Arlington on Saturday in my edition).

No significant coverage of global racing by an expert like Alan Shuback

No Peb cover drawing for the Kentucky Derby
Barry Irwin - Additional Interesting Remarks

I do believe that one of the storylines that will be developed over the next two weeks until Preakness Day will by Barry Irwin and his rather controversial remarks about parts of the horse racing industry. When a guy who wins the Derby and has a tear in his eye says "I got tired of trainers lying to me", I think it's a legitimate story.

There are plenty of racing industry actions that deserve criticism. But Irwin has earned widespread condemnation within racing - Indian Charlie had a cartoon in his pre-Derby edition that seems to represent many racing people's opinion of him:

http://www.indiancharlie.com/2011/05/05/friday-saturday-may-6-7-2011/


A few other remarks by Irwin at the Derby post-race press conference - the first one I would agree with completely:

ON INTERNATIONAL RACING:

"Well, I've always liked international racing, even when I was a turf writer. It's more interesting. I'm the kind of guy that gets bored very easily. I need a lot of different things to do.

Following international racing is a lot of fun. I also think that we have not done enough importing of horses and blood lines from other places where horses don't run on drugs and horses legs are not manipulated and horses, basically, are bigger and tougher, stronger and sounder.

And we have won a couple of big races now in the last six months, we won the Breeders' Cup with a horse that was out of a mare that I brought from South Africa, and this is a horse that I bought in Germany.

In Germany, you are not allowed to breed a mare that has ever raced on drugs, Lasix, Bute, nothing. So when you buy some stock from there, you know you're getting something good. So that's where I'm coming from."

ON RACING OWNERSHIP PARTNERSHIPS & RACETRACKS:

"I think this was a big weekend for the partnerships, Peachtree, Todd won a race today we won this. I hope these racetracks pay attention to the partnerships and treat us a little better than they have been treating us."
Barry Irwin and Horse Trainers

Immediately after winning the 2011 Kentucky Derby with Animal Kingdom, Barry Irwin was interview by NBC's Bob Neumeier. Neumeier asked Irwin why had had shifted all of Team Valor's horses (including Animal Kingdom) under Graham Motion in November - his response was "I was tired of trainers lying to me. I wanted a guy to tell me the truth."

At the Derby post-race press conference, Irwin expanded upon his earlier remark:

"Well, it's a combination of things. This is my 25th year racing horses for a syndicate. I started in 1987. And I've done this a long time. I'm 68 years old. I've reached the point where I still want to work hard, so then I don't want to have 18 trainers. I don't want to hear stories from 17 trainers every day.

Unless you're there and you have one guy on your team that's on your side, you're not going to get the truth. And I reached the point where I was fed up with it. I also wanted to have my horses trained off‑site from the racetrack, because racetrack life for a horse isn't any good. And we found Fair Hill, which is, I wouldn't say it's a paradise for horses, but it's the closest thing to a European training center that we have in America.

We have had horses with Graham for the last three years. I asked him early last year if he would train horses for us on a private basis. He didn't want to do it. So we waited about six, seven months, after he had a little more chance to work with me, and I asked him again, and he decided to do it, and then we decided to go that way.

It's hard to find one guy that can train every kind of horse, but I think Graham comes pretty darned close. We gave him a young two‑year‑old by the same sire as Animal Kingdom and he ran second is first time out of Keeneland, four and a half furloughs. Any guy that can win a Derby and run a horse four and a half furloughs is my kind of guy."
Barry Irwin Knows Racing History?

At the post-Derby press conference, Team Valor's Barry Irwin stated according to the official transcript:

"The other thought is, I like to try to make history if I can, and we made a lot of history today. This is the first horse that came to win this race with only four previous races, since Exterminator in 1918, the first horse to win after a six‑week layoff since Needles in 1956 so that means a lot to me."

Big Brown won the Derby in 2008 off a mere three starts.
Zayat Stable at the Derby

Jay Privman in DRF had good article on Ahmad Zayat in their Derby preview issue


Zayat has now had a horse that at the top of the stretch looked like the winner in two of last three years - Pioneer of the Nile in 2009 and Nehro this year - before being caught in the final eighth of a mile. In 2010 they had Eskendereya who was Derby favorite who was withdrawn a week before the race.

A book could be written on Derby hard luck stories and it would include a chapter on Zayat's past three years.





Friday, May 06, 2011

2011 Derby Storylines

Here are the storylines for Derby 137:

Archarcharch - 70 year old trainer Jinks Fires in his first Derby charge, 50 year old Jon Court (trainer's son-in-law), Arkansas owners who rebuffed offers to buy horse pre-Derby. Great story.

Brilliant Speed - Live Oak's To Honor and Serve was top 5 for Derby in winter book - 2nd stringer takes the prize for Campbell Soup heir

Twice the Appeal - Calvin wins again

Stay Thirsty - Pletcher/Repole combo wins race after scratch of 2 year old champion and winter book favs Uncle Mo on the day before the race

Decisive Moment - Trainer Juan Arias wins race like his namesake with Canonero II forty years ago and 52 year old Kerwin "Boo Boo" Clark wins race on his first mount.

Comma to the Top - Will he or won't he horse wins with 49 year old P Val twenty two years since his first win on Sunday Silence.

Pants On Fire - Jockey Rosie Napravnik becomes first female to win the race

Dialed In - The confirmation of the arrival of a great horse and the tears flow from trainer Nick Zito on his 3rd Derby win

Derby Kitten - Last horse to get into race wins it for his exuberant owner Ken Ramsey

Twinspired - 45 year old jockey Mike Smith wins his 2nd Derby

Master of Hounds - "foreigner" in race shows further demise of American racing

Santiva - no idea on this one - will probably win

Mucho Macho Man - first female trainer Kathy Ritvo wins race after heart transplant. Watch for the full-length movie in 20 years.

Shackleford - wise guy horse wins it for local trainer Dale Romans

Midnight Interlude - trainer Bob Baffert wins his fourth Derby to break the streak of no unraced 2 year old winning race since Apollo in 1882

Animal Kingdom - provides redemption for jockey Johnny V (after losing mount due to Uncle Mo fiasco) and trainer Graham Motion (who lost top contender Toby's Corner this week)

Soldat - trainer Kiaran McLaughlin wins race to redeem 2nd with Closing Argument in 2005

Nehro - backrupt owner Zayat Stable wins big one with comebacking Corey Nakatani to redeem for Zayat's Eskendereya - last year's Derby runup favorite

Watch Me Go - first female trainer wins race for longtime owner/breeder Gilbert Campbell

Three horse are grandsons of AP Indy - 1992 Derby runup favorite scratched on day of race and recently pensioned - Stay Thirsty, Pants On Fire, Nehro.

Take your pick.

Stay Thirsty, my friends.





Wednesday, May 04, 2011

Deservingness of Derby Win

Winning the Kentucky Derby should always be the privilege of horsemen and horsewomen who deserve the honor based on their time and service to the racing industry. Winners like Sea Hero in 1993 for trainer Mack Miller and owner Paul Mellon, Unbridled in 1990 for trainer Carl Nafzger and owner Francis Genter, and Swale in 1984 for Claiborne Farm.

So with this in mind, I have rated this year's Derby field based on "Deservingness" - a purely arbitrary ranking based on my own perspective:

Archarcharch - Local favorite for 70 year old trainer Jinks Fires making his Derby debut with son-in-law Jon Court in the irons and owners who rejected selling a top 3 year old to "foreigners". This is a very worthy team.

Brilliant Speed - Charlotte Weber has one of the finest homebred racing operations in the country running Live Oak Plantation since 1995.

Watch Me Go - Gilbert Campbell is a longtime Florida breeder who also has a solid homebred racing operation.

Dialed In - Robert LaPenta has been building his top-notch racing stable for a decade and has suffered 3 year old disappointment in the past with War Pass.

Derby Kitten - Ken and Sarah Ramsey are long-time racing benefactors and homebred owners

Animal Kingdom - Barry Irwin - chief honcho of Team Valor - maybe an arrogant, abrasive individual but he has been involved in racing for over 20 years.

Master of the Hounds - Coolmore already has one Derby winner with Thunder Gulch in 1995.

Johnny Come Latelys - Arnold Zetcher, Mike Repole, Lori and George Hall and Ahmad Zayat can all be included in this category. They are not worthy of Derby Glory yet.
Jerry's Thoughts

As always, Jerry Brown provides his informative opinion on Derby-Oaks 137. His key contenders:

Derby - Archarcharch, Soldat, Mucho Macho Man, Pants On Fire

Oaks - Joyful Victory, Zazu, Kathmanblu & Her Smile (who Bobby Flay purchased based on Thoro-Graph recommendation)

Jerry doesn't think much of Dialed In or Uncle Mo.
Jerry and The Derby

Always enjoy listening to Thoro-Graph's Jerry Brown's comments on Derby and Breeders Cup days via his annual online audiovisual seminars. Derby/Oaks seminar is not up yet.

I'm going to forecast which horses Jerry will look favorably on in each race:

Derby - Santiva, Soldat, Stay Thirsty, Pants on Fire
Oaks - Daisy Devine, St. John's River, Kathmanblu


Alan Shuback Dismissed from DRF

The global correspondent for Daily Racing Form since 1993 - Alan Shuback - has parted ways with the publication. Shuback often had controversial views towards American horses vis-a-vis their European counterparts (voting for Goldikova for 2010 Horse of the Year for example) but he obviously knew the racing world very well and I will miss his writing in the Form and DRF.com.

Daily Racing Form continues to match the decline of the industry they are covering - dismissing a quality writer like Shuback and no longer printing the entries for smaller racetracks in the Form.

Friday, April 22, 2011

Prairie Meadows Opens Tonight

Prairie Meadows opens their 22nd season of racing this evening. Perennial leading rider Terry Thompson returns (after a year hiatus riding at Delaware Park) and young Jenna Joubert has also moved her tack there from Oaklawn. Des Moines Register has a good article on the top races in history run at Prairie:

Monday, April 18, 2011

Keeneland Grade I Stakes Results on Polytrack

Jeremy Plonk has a nice article in the Keeneland spring program with headline of "Don't let the big races fool you" with a smaller secondary headline under stating "Longshots in Grade 1 races belie true picture of winners on Polytrack".

Obviously since this is written for the Keeneland program, no bad word on Polytrack would be expected in the article. The main argument is that Polytrack is a very formful surface with favorites winning 31% of races (stats through last Fall's meeting) since the Polytrack Era began at the Fall 2006 meeting. Favorites won 41% of races on the Polytrack at the 2010 Fall meeting but currently (through April 17) winning only 20.7% at the Spring meeting.

There is prominent attention paid to the great exception of all this - the results of Grade 1 races on Polytrack. Here are the stats for Grade I races on Polytrack at Keeneland through the Blue Grass last Saturday:

Total Races - 27
Winning Favorites - 1
Percentage of Winning Favorites - 3.7%

2011 Grade I winners on Polytrack at Keeneland

Ashland - Lilacs and Lace paid $99.40
Madison - Shotgun Gulch paid $25.40
Blue Grass - Brilliant Speed paid $40.20

The only favorite to win Grade I on Polytrack at Keeneland was Wickedly Perfect winning the 2010 Alcibiades last fall.

A few final comments on this article - which is very good and there should be more like it that are statistically based:

1) The fact favorites are winning at a greater rate on the Polytrack is very likely due to handicappers becoming more familiar with the surface and it's similarity closer to turf racing than dirt racing.

2) Keeneland has taken their greatest race - the Blue Grass - and made it irreverent as a prep for the Derby due to Polytrack.

3) Every track should have a Polycapping database like Keeneland has on their website.

4) It would be interesting to see a similar study on other Polytrack sites like Arlington, Del Mar and Woodbine.


Saturday, April 16, 2011

Final Day at Oaklawn

Arkansas Derby Day ends the 85th racing season at Oaklawn Park today. The usual throng of 50,000 plus will storm the gates of the old Central Avenue plant making Hot Springs temporarily the second most populated city in Arkansas after Little Rock.

Favorites are winning approximately 31% of the races this season at the Spa - down from 41% of favorites in 2003 according to the Arkansas Gazette-Democrat website. Oaklawn is my favorite track to bet especially in the opening two months of the season with full fields and horses running from all parts of the country.

Oaklawn to me means racing consistency. The season will begin in mid-late January, it will end three weeks prior to the Kentucky Derby, Terry Wallace will always be at the mike and will put a goofy hat on at least once during the meet. He will pause prior to announcing the track condition and wear a tuxedo on Arkansas Derby Day. There is always a Cella running the track and usually running horses there too. Oaklawn and Keeneland are the only tracks I know that on the first day of the meeting show the replays from the previous meeting (for Oaklawn, these are races nine months previous). The weather in the final six weeks of the meeting is usually beautiful springtime weather. Stanley Roberts, Don Von Hemel, Gary Hartlage, Scooter Dickey, Lynn Whiting, Jinks Fires and Bob Holthus always have a winner during the meeting. The racing surface during the Racing Festival of the South will be lightning fast favoring speed. The exotica wagering menu will drive you crazy with only a few races with superfectas - I discussed this with Mel Brooks in a Vegas racebook once who couldn't believe they didn't have more supers.

Keeneland's consistency ended with Polytrack. They have ruined a great American race - the Blue Grass Stakes. I don't enjoy wagering on Keeneland nearly as much as I once did.

The Oaklawn simulcast feed is showing the crowd ontrack today - that's another great thing about Hot Springs - the area supports the track throughout the meeting ending with today's huge crowd.

Friday, April 15, 2011

Turf Publicists of America

Racetracks need turf publicists. There are virtually no newspaper dedicated turf writers anymore (i.e. reporters who cover racing exclusively) outside of the newspapers in Lexington and Louisville (I'm not even sure about Louisville). When you have two declining industries together - newspapers and horse racing - this is what results.

I find this very sad since without turf writers covers the racing scene on a daily basis, we only have racetrack turf publicists to rely on to dig up and generate interesting stories on horse racing. NYRA and the California tracks post regular turf notes on their websites and they provide a daily glimpse into the racetracks and upcoming stakes races. It is inconceivable that a daily sport like baseball would be in a similar situation - no one covering the sport on a regular basis to provide human and equine interest stories and report on milestone events in the sport.

Robert Holthus' win with Fifth Avenue South in the first race at Oaklawn Park last week had to be a milestone of some sort - allowing Holthus to continue with saddling a winner at Oaklawn since sometime in the 1960's (probably 1964). The only media mention of this that I have found is on Arkansas Online - the website of the Arkansas Democrat Gazette of Little Rock. Even the Oaklawn website had no mention of this milestone. Incredible. Holthus has been a fixture at the track for decades and deserves better recognition for continuing to saddle winners amidst health issues at the age of 76.

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Uncle Mo is Not Out of the Derby

DRF has latest status of the 2 year old champion and winter book favorite for the Derby:

Uncle Mo Out of Derby

Roger Stein - while interviewing Bob Baffert this morning - said that Uncle Mo had been declared out of the Kentucky Derby. I don't see this being confirmed anywhere but Stein is usually accurate on this stuff.

Saturday, April 09, 2011

Uncle Mo Loss in the Wood - Where On Derby Trail Are We Now?

There have been 136 previous preparatory seasons to the Kentucky Derby (aka the Derby Trail). This year on May 7 we will celebrate Derby 137. There also was a Derby Trail in some of the years previous to origination of the Kentucky Derby in 1875. The first Derby Trail article that I have found was in the New York Times in the spring of 1864 previewing the racers preparing for America's first Derby - the Jersey Derby - held at the new race course at Paterson, NJ. The 1864 crop of three year olds was outstanding featuring sire Lexington's great triumvirate - Kentucky, Norfolk, and Asteroid.

So we have a rich American Derby Trail history without even considering the history of other global Derbies run at Epsom or Chantilly. The past can be categorized and analyzed based on patterns of previous results. It is obvious that the Derby Trail that we are now living and examining can be called "Two Year Old Champion and Heavy Winter Book Favorite Loses Final Prep Race".

The most obvious historical comparison is Secretariat's Derby year of 1973 when he also ran third in the 47th running of the Wood Memorial at Aqueduct on April 21, 1973 to his stablemate Angle Light (entry went off at 3-10) with Sham running a close second beaten by a head. Expect NBC to highlight this "Angle" during their pre-race coverage in four weeks (after they have exhausted interviewing all B-List celebrities at Churchill).

Perusing Champions (great book of historic past performances that DRF Press should continually update and expand upon), I found other relevant examples:

1936 - Pompoon was 2 year old champion and started his three year old campaign with a neck win in the Paumonok Handicap against older horses (for many years the traditional stake race to open the New York racing season at Jamaica). Pompoon then ran fifth in the Wood Memorial as 3-5 favs - he would go off at 8-1 in the Derby and run 2nd to Lawrin whose successful Florida winter campaign was the first to lead to Derby glory.

1939 - El Chico was the undefeated 2 year old champion and heavy winter book favorite for the Derby. El Chico made his three year old debut in an allowance race at Aqueduct on April 15 running second beaten a nose as part of 1-5 favored entry. He subsequently was impeded on the first turn and never a factor in the Wood Memorial that Belair Stud's Johnstown won by eight lengths as 1-2 favorite. His running line reads "quit" in posting a sixth in the Derby at 8-1. The great columnist John Lardner foresaw these events in a column published on March 8 predicting Johnstown subsequent Derby win.

1961 - Carry Back took over as Derby favorite in the fall of his 2 year old campaign after leading two year old Hail to Reason was retired due to injury on September 18 and victories in Cowdin, Garden State and Remsen. He ran six times in Florida (yes, hard to believe compared to Mo's ridiculous one race farce) winning the Flamingo and the Florida Derby. He was shipped to New York and ran 2nd as even money favorite in the Wood. He bounced back to win the Derby two weeks later.

Overall, historic patterns looks pretty good for Uncle Mo as long as he stays healthy and makes the trip to Churchill. Three of the four similar Winter Book favorites ran first or second in the Derby after losing their final prep in the Wood. I would think there are some similar results with a Winter Book favorite losing final Derby prep in the Derby Trial but I wasn't able to find one in Champions.
Prohibitive Derby Favorite Loses and No One Cares

Not only has horse racing lost all mainstream national television coverage during the current Derby Trail season but it has obviously lost any relevance at all until Kentucky Derby Day on May 7. The undefeated two year old champion and Kentucky Derby winter book favorite Uncle Mo was defeated today in the Wood Memorial as the 1-10 favorite. This event has not been noticed according to my review of the past of few hours on the following websites: ESPN, NY Times, CBS Sports and Fox Sports. It is the thirteenth of 13 Top Stories linked to on the Sports Illustrated website.

I fondly recall the thrill of watching countless Derby preps on the national networks in my youth of the 1970's and 1980's when it would be unimaginable that races such as the Florida Derby, the Wood, Blue Grass or the Santa Anita Derby would not be televised nationally. The sport of horse racing in the United States has been reduced to a two week season of national prominence (Kentucky Derby Day to Preakness Day) with the only exception being years when the Derby winner wins the Preakness and three more weeks of exposure through the Belmont Stakes.

I do understand the myriad of alternative options that people have to watch these events. But that doesn't hide the fact that this sport has lost all relevance with the general public outside of the two week Triple Crown window and industry geographic strongholds like Kentucky, Saratoga Springs, and Del Mar.
Bob Holthus Wins Again at Oaklawn Park

Bob Holthus - longtime leading trainer at Oaklawn - broke his O for 18 duck for the meeting today with a win by Fifth Avenue South in the first race paying $31.40.

Holthus has been winning races at Oaklawn since the early sixties - he has probably won a race at every meeting since 1964. Of course I doubt Oaklawn has any statistics on this - it will be interesting if they post anything on their website on this accomplishment.



Flat Bet Profit on all Jenna Joubert Mounts at Oaklawn

Jenna won her third race at Oaklawn on Sunday, April 3 scoring on an Arkansas bred first timer trained by David Morris who went off at 38-1! As of the end of racing at Oaklawn on Friday, April 8, Jenna's stats for the meeting were the following:

63 mounts 3 wins - 2 seconds - 7 thirds total purse money won $97,276

Equibase based statistics

A flat $2 bet on each of Jenna's mounts for the meeting would yield a positive return of $62.20 for a 49% percent return on investment! This is better than buying gold these days!